Most plants are good at firefighting. Something breaks, people jump on it, production restarts. Next month the same problem is back. The most expensive thing in manufacturing is solving the exact same problem twice.
Lean problem solving finds the root cause so the problem stays fixed. Three tools do most of the work:
- 5 whys: ask why until you reach a cause you can act on. The machine stopped. Why? A fuse blew. Why? The motor overloaded. Why? The bearing seized. Why? Nobody lubricated it. Why? That machine isn't on the lubrication schedule. Now you have something to fix, and it isn't the fuse. Five is a guide, not a rule.
- A3: a one-page problem-solving report, named after the A3 paper size. It takes one problem from background, current condition and goal through root cause, countermeasures, plan and follow-up. One page forces clear thinking, and anyone can check the reasoning.
- PDCA: plan, do, check, act. Plan the countermeasure, try it, check with data whether it worked, then act: make it the standard if it did, or go round again if it didn't. The A3 follows the same loop.
The lesson's 5 whys, drawn out
- ProblemThe machine stopped.
- Why? (1)A fuse blew.
- Why? (2)The motor overloaded.
- Why? (3)The bearing seized.
- Why? (4)Nobody lubricated it.
- Why? (5)Root cause you can act onThat machine isn't on the lubrication schedule.
PDCA, the loop the A3 follows
- 1PlanPlan the countermeasure.
- 2DoTry it.
- 3CheckCheck with data whether it worked.
- 4ActMake it the standard, or go round again.
Two traps:
- Stopping at operator error: if the root cause is a person, keep asking. Why was the mistake possible in the first place?
- Weak countermeasures: if the fix is retraining, a reminder or an extra inspection, the investigation stopped early. Look for a change to the process that makes the problem hard or impossible to repeat.
Your action for today
Take one problem that has come back at least twice this year. Sit down with two people who deal with it and run a 5 whys on a whiteboard. Don't accept human error as an answer. Write down the countermeasure and the date you'll check whether it worked.
A free A3 problem solving template with a filled-in example (your 5 whys goes in the root cause box):
A3 problem solving templateGo deeper
The lesson covers the 5 whys, the A3 and PDCA. These pages help you choose a method and see one worked through.
- Problem solving methods
The common methods side by side with when to use each one, for the day a problem is too big for the 5 whys and too small for a project.
- 5 whys examples
Ten worked chains from production, quality, safety and maintenance, each with the evidence behind every why and the wrong turn that was available.
- A3 problem solving guide
Each section of the A3 with a filled example from a plant, and how it compares with 8D and PDCA.
- Root cause analysis guide
The steps from a clear problem statement to a verified cause, and the tools for finding causes, from fishbone to Pareto.
Check what you learned
Three questions on this lesson. Get 2 right and the lesson counts as done on your course page.
Want this saved? Sign up free for your own course page and each finished lesson is ticked. Get my course page

