Free tool
Lean maturity self-assessment
A lean maturity assessment scores how far a site's lean system has developed, area by area, so you can see which part holds the rest back. Rate 27 statements from 1 to 5 across nine dimensions: leadership, daily management, standard work, problem solving, CI culture, flow, quality, people and safety. You get a score and a band for each dimension and overall, where to start, and the guides to read for every low area. No sign-up.
Dimension scoreequalsSum of its 3 answers divided by 3
Overall scoreequalsSum of all 27 answers divided by 27
Score each statement for your site as it is today, not as it is meant to be. Think of what you have seen in the last month.
1 Not in place · 2 Started · 3 In some areas · 4 In most areas · 5 Everywhere, sustained
1. Leadership
How leaders set direction, show up at the gemba and coach.
2. Daily management
How teams review performance every day and get problems answered.
3. Standard work
Whether the best known way of doing each job is written, followed and kept current.
4. Problem solving
Whether problems are solved at the root, with facts from where they happen.
5. CI culture
Whether everyone improves their own work, and whether improvements are noticed and shared.
6. Flow
How smoothly work moves at the pace of demand, with little waiting and stock.
7. Quality
Whether quality is built in at each step instead of inspected in at the end.
8. People
Whether people have the skills, cover and time to do the work and improve it.
9. Safety
Whether hazards are found and removed before they hurt someone, and people speak up.
Your result
0 of 27 answered
Each dimension's score appears when its three statements are answered, and the overall result when all 27 are.
- Leadership0 of 3
- Daily management0 of 3
- Standard work0 of 3
- Problem solving0 of 3
- CI culture0 of 3
- Flow0 of 3
- Quality0 of 3
- People0 of 3
- Safety0 of 3
Example scoring model made for this page: equal weights, a plain average and round band cut-offs. It is not a certified standard or a validated instrument.
Next step
Want to act on this score?
Bring this result to a 45-minute demo and we will show where it fits in LeanSuite's Audit Management.
How the scoring works
Score what you see, then start with the lowest dimension
Score the site as it is today. A practice that runs in one model area but not elsewhere is a 2 or a 3, not a 5. A 5 means it runs everywhere and survives a change of supervisor or a busy month.
Every dimension counts the same. Each has three statements, so the overall score is simply the average of all 27 answers. There are no hidden weights.
Start with the lowest dimension. Lean practices lean on each other: problem solving is hard without standards to compare against, and daily meetings fade without leaders who show up. The next steps begin with the dimension that scores lowest.
Read up on every low area. Any dimension below 3.0 gets a short list of free guides, such as root cause analysis for problem solving or near miss reporting for safety.
Ask more than one person. Have leaders, supervisors and operators score on their own and compare. For a pre-rollout check instead, use the lean readiness assessment template.
Worked example
Illustrative numbers, not a benchmarkA components plant that has run lean for two years scores itself. Daily huddles and 5S are in place on most lines, but standards are out of date, problems keep coming back and near misses wait weeks for an answer.
The example plant's nine dimensions
- Leadership3.3 of 5
Established
- Daily management3.7 of 5
Established
- Standard workLowest2.3 of 5
Developing
- Problem solvingLowest2.3 of 5
Developing
- CI culture2.7 of 5
Developing
- Flow2.7 of 5
Developing
- Quality3.0 of 5
Established
- PeopleLowest2.3 of 5
Developing
- Safety2.7 of 5
Developing
Overall 2.8 on the four bands
Bands: Starting from 1.0 to 1.9, Developing from 2.0 to 2.9, Established from 3.0 to 3.9, Sustaining from 4.0 to 5.0. The overall score 2.8 is in Developing.
Scores out of 5: Leadership 3.3 (Established), Daily management 3.7 (Established), Standard work 2.3 (Developing), Problem solving 2.3 (Developing), CI culture 2.7 (Developing), Flow 2.7 (Developing), Quality 3.0 (Established), People 2.3 (Developing), Safety 2.7 (Developing). Overall 2.8, Developing. Lowest: standard work, problem solving, people, all at 2.3.
Step 1
Leadership 4, 3, 3 = 10 ÷ 3 = 3.3, Established. Daily management 4, 4, 3 = 3.7, Established.Step 2
Standard work 2, 2, 3 = 2.3, Developing. Problem solving 2, 3, 2 = 2.3, Developing.Step 3
CI culture 3, 3, 2 = 2.7. Flow 3, 2, 3 = 2.7. Quality 3, 3, 3 = 3.0. People 3, 2, 2 = 2.3. Safety 3, 3, 2 = 2.7.Step 4
Overall = 75 ÷ 27 = 2.8, Developing.Step 5
Lowest: standard work, problem solving and people, all at 2.3. Six dimensions are below 3.0, so six get guides to read.
The nine dimensions
What each dimension covers, and the first guide to read when it scores low. The statements are short on purpose: score them with an example from the floor in mind.
- Leadership
- How leaders set direction, show up at the gemba and coach.Read first: What is a gemba walk
- Daily management
- How teams review performance every day and get problems answered.Read first: Manufacturing KPIs and tiered review
- Standard work
- Whether the best known way of doing each job is written, followed and kept current.Read first: SOP meaning and format
- Problem solving
- Whether problems are solved at the root, with facts from where they happen.Read first: Problem solving methods compared
- CI culture
- Whether everyone improves their own work, and whether improvements are noticed and shared.Read first: Kaizen
- Flow
- How smoothly work moves at the pace of demand, with little waiting and stock.Read first: Just-in-time manufacturing
- Quality
- Whether quality is built in at each step instead of inspected in at the end.Read first: Poka-yoke
- People
- Whether people have the skills, cover and time to do the work and improve it.Read first: Lean in 7 days, a free course
- Safety
- Whether hazards are found and removed before they hurt someone, and people speak up.Read first: Near miss reporting
Lean maturity levels on the floor
The four bands, with what one dimension, daily management, looks like in each. Use descriptions like these to settle an argument about whether a practice is a 2 or a 4.
| Band | Score | Daily management on the floor |
|---|---|---|
| Starting | 1.0 to 1.9 | One line has a whiteboard. It is filled in when the supervisor has time, and nobody outside the line looks at it. |
| Developing | 2.0 to 2.9 | Most lines hold a huddle, but it slips on busy shifts. Escalated problems wait days for an answer. |
| Established | 3.0 to 3.9 | Every team huddles at the same time at a board with targets. Managers walk the boards and close escalations within a day. |
| Sustaining | 4.0 to 5.0 | The routine survives a new supervisor and a peak month. Teams change their own boards when a measure stops helping. |
Where the dimensions come from
The statements and the scoring are our own. The choice of dimensions draws on published work, named here so you can go to the source. None of it is reproduced on this page.
- The Shingo Model from the Shingo Institute at Utah State University, which assesses culture through behaviour rather than tools. Our summary: 10 principles of operational excellence.
- David Mann, Creating a Lean Culture, for leader standard work, visual controls and daily accountability as the routines that keep lean tools in use. These shape the leadership and daily management dimensions.
- Mike Rother, Toyota Kata, for leaders as coaches of problem solving, and Jeffrey Liker, The Toyota Way, for building in quality and stopping to fix problems.
- SAE J4000, a 1999 SAE standard for scoring how fully lean practices are in place, and the Capability Maturity Model from Carnegie Mellon for the idea of maturity levels.
Safety is a dimension of its own because a common tiered review runs in the order safety, quality, delivery, cost, people (SQDCP), and a lean system that hurts people is not mature. See manufacturing KPIs for that structure.
How to run it with your team
- Pick the scope: one site, or one value stream if the site is large. Everyone scores the same scope.
- Choose five to eight people across levels: plant manager, a supervisor per shift, operators, quality, maintenance.
- Each person scores alone, from what they saw in the last month. Plan about 15 minutes.
- Put the scores side by side. Where two people are two or more points apart, walk that area together before agreeing a number.
- Agree one or two dimensions to work on, usually the lowest. Give each an owner and a date.
- Read the guides for those dimensions, then pick one next step from the result and start it this month.
- Score again in six to twelve months with the same people and scope, and compare.
Common mistakes
- Scoring the plan, not the floor. A procedure that exists on the shared drive but is not followed is a 1 or a 2.
- One person scoring for the whole site. The CI lead's view and the night shift's view can be a point or more apart.
- Averaging away the disagreement. A 2 and a 5 that average to 3.5 hide the most useful finding.
- Working on the strongest dimension because it is the most fun. The lowest one is usually what stalls the rest.
- Turning the score into a target. Once a bonus depends on it, people score higher and the floor stays the same.
- Comparing sites scored by different people. Use the same assessors, or at least one in common, before ranking sites.
- Re-scoring every month. Routines take months to settle; frequent runs measure mood, not maturity.
Embed this assessment
Teaching this, or writing about it? Paste this code into your site, course page or intranet and the assessment works right there. It is free, with no sign-up.
<iframe src="https://www.theleansuite.com/tools/lean-maturity-assessment/embed" title="Lean maturity self-assessment by LeanSuite" width="100%" height="6300" style="border:0;max-width:1000px" loading="lazy" allow="clipboard-write"></iframe>
<p style="font:13px/1.4 sans-serif"><a href="https://www.theleansuite.com/tools/lean-maturity-assessment">Lean maturity self-assessment</a> by LeanSuite</p>How LeanSuite helps
In LeanSuite you can build an assessment like this in Lean Creator with rating questions, schedule it in Daily Standard Work with a repeat rule, and set rules on the answers that raise actions automatically.
See Audit ManagementRead more
- Free template: Lean readiness assessment template
- Free template: Operational excellence assessment template
- Free template: TQM self-assessment template
- Lean transformation in the lean glossary
- Lean Transformation: A Complete Guide for Beginners
- What is operational excellence
- Lean tools: every tool in one place
- Operational excellence in the lean glossary
- Lean Readiness Assessment: Complete Guide
- Implementing Lean Manufacturing: 5-Phase Roadmap
FAQ
Lean maturity self-assessment: common questions
A lean maturity assessment scores how far a site's lean system has developed, area by area, such as leadership, daily management, standard work, problem solving, flow, quality and safety. It shows which parts are strong and which hold the rest back, so you know where to work next. Repeated every six to twelve months, it shows whether the system is improving.
Each of the 27 statements is scored from 1 (not in place) to 5 (everywhere, sustained). A dimension's score is the average of its three statements, and the overall score is the average of all 27, so every dimension counts the same. Scores are rounded to one decimal and read against four bands: Starting below 2.0, Developing from 2.0, Established from 3.0 and Sustaining from 4.0. It is an example model made for this page, not a certified standard.
This page uses four: Starting, Developing, Established and Sustaining. Many published maturity models use five levels, an idea that goes back to the Capability Maturity Model from Carnegie Mellon's Software Engineering Institute. The number matters less than what each level looks like on your floor, so every band here has a plain description and the page shows what daily management looks like in each one.
Every dimension below 3.0 (the Starting and Developing bands) gets a list of guides to read next, lowest dimension first, plus a next step and free templates for its band. If nothing is below 3.0, you get the guides for your lowest dimension.
A readiness assessment is done before a lean rollout, to check the foundation lean depends on, such as leadership commitment and stable processes. This maturity assessment is for a site that already runs lean practices and wants to see how far each part has come. The free lean readiness assessment template on this site covers the first case.
Several people on their own: leaders, supervisors, operators and support staff, including people who are not enthusiasts. Compare their results before discussing them. Where scores differ a lot, go and look at the floor together before deciding which view is right.
Every six to twelve months for the whole assessment. Practices take months to settle, so scoring every few weeks mostly measures mood. Between full runs, re-score only the dimension you are working on, for example each quarter.
Yes. A new plant manager, a lost supervisor or a hard quarter can stop huddles, checks and gemba walks within weeks. That is why a 5 here means the practice survives a change of people. A drop between two runs is useful: it shows which routine depended on one person.
No. A low score on the first run is normal and gives you a baseline. What matters is whether the lowest dimension moves up on the next run, and whether the gaps between dimensions shrink.
Yes. The operational excellence assessment template and the TQM self-assessment template on this site let several people score the same statements and work out averages and the spread between them in Excel.
No. The assessment is scored in your browser and the full result shows straight away. Nothing is saved unless you choose to email yourself the results. The link to your results carries your answers as digits in the address, so anyone you send it to sees the same scores.
More free lean tools
All tools- OEE calculatorOverall equipment effectiveness from shift time, downtime, ideal cycle time and part counts.
- Downtime cost calculatorWhat an hour, an event and a year of unplanned downtime cost, from lost output, idle labour, scrap and overtime.
- SMED changeover calculatorTime saved by moving changeover steps from internal to external, capacity freed per week and the smaller batch it allows.
- Takt time calculatorThe pace a line must hit to meet customer demand, from shift time, breaks and daily demand.
- Cycle time calculatorCycle time against takt, units per hour, capacity per shift and the gap to daily demand.
- Line balancing calculatorLine efficiency, balance delay and the minimum number of stations from station times and takt.
- Bottleneck calculatorThe step that limits your line, from each step's cycle time, machines and uptime, with daily capacity and the gap to demand.
- First pass yield (FPY) calculatorFirst pass yield at each step and rolled throughput yield (RTY) across the whole process.
- Cost of poor quality (COPQ) calculatorTotal COPQ and cost of quality, and each as a share of revenue, from the four quality cost categories.
- Process capability (Cp, Cpk) calculatorCp and Cpk against your specification limits, plus Pp and Ppk from pasted measurements, with a distribution chart.
- DPMO and sigma level calculatorDPMO, defects per unit, yield and sigma level from the defects found, units checked and opportunities per unit.
- MTBF and MTTR calculatorMean time between failures, mean time to repair and availability from operating time, failures and repair time.
- Lead time calculatorManufacturing lead time from WIP and throughput (Little's Law), and the share of it that adds value.
- Throughput time calculatorThroughput time from process, inspection, move and wait time, the share of it that adds value, and units per hour.
- Kaizen savings calculatorYearly savings, payback in months and first-year ROI of an improvement, from time saved, scrap avoided and its costs.
- TEEP calculatorTotal effective equipment performance: OEE multiplied by how much of all calendar time you plan to run.
- Overall labor effectiveness (OLE) calculatorHow well paid labor hours turn into good output: availability, performance and quality of the crew.
- Inventory turnover and days on hand calculatorHow many times stock turns over in a period and how many days of it you hold, from COGS and average inventory.
- Safety stock calculatorSafety stock and reorder point from the service level you want, average demand and lead time, and how much each varies.
- Scrap rate calculatorScrap rate, the cost of scrap per period and per year, and what reaching a target rate would save.
- TRIR and DART rate calculatorOSHA recordable and DART incident rates from your 300A case counts and hours, and what one more case does to them.
- NIOSH lifting equation calculatorRecommended weight limit and lifting index for a two-handed lift, with every multiplier shown so you can see what to redesign.
- Time study sample size calculatorHow many cycles of an element to time, from your first readings, with the t formula, the ILO formula and the range method.
- Maintenance strategy selectorAnswer the RCM questions for one failure mode and get the maintenance strategy, the reasoning and the check or test interval.
- Noise dose and TWA calculatorDose and 8-hour TWA for a shift of noise levels under OSHA and NIOSH, which limits are reached and how much loud time to cut.
- Risk matrix calculatorSeverity times likelihood on a 3 x 3, 4 x 4 or 5 x 5 risk matrix, the band and its action, editable banding, and the score after further controls.
- Repair or replace calculatorEquivalent annual cost of keeping and repairing an old machine against buying a new one, with each one's economic life and the break-even figures.
- Compressed air leak cost calculatorAir lost, kW and cost a year for each tagged leak from its size and the pressure, ranked so the biggest gets fixed first.
- Machine hour rate calculatorWhat one productive hour of a machine costs, with and without the operator, the cost per part and how utilisation moves the rate.
- Total manufacturing cost calculatorTotal manufacturing cost, cost of goods manufactured, cost per unit and the overhead rate from materials, labor and overhead.
- Acceptance sampling calculatorRead the OC curve and the real risks of a sampling plan, find the plan for your AQL and LTPD, or size a zero-defect test.
- Shift schedule plannerTen shift patterns on real dates: calendar for each crew, hours a week, weekends off, coverage and the weeks over 40 hours.
- Pareto chart makerPaste categories and counts: sorted bars, cumulative percentage line and the vital few at the 80% line, as a PNG or SVG.
- Histogram makerPaste measurements: the histogram with automatic or chosen bins, plus mean, median and standard deviation, as a PNG or SVG.
- Box plot makerPaste one or more groups of numbers: box plots with quartiles, IQR, whiskers and outliers by the 1.5 IQR rule, as a PNG or SVG.
- Fishbone diagram makerName the problem, list causes under the 6M bones, and download the Ishikawa diagram as a PNG or SVG.
- 5 Whys canvasWrite the problem, answer up to five whys, state the root cause and countermeasure, then print the one-page canvas.
- Lean method navigatorSix questions about one problem, then the lean method to start with, the two that follow, why each fits, five steps for Monday and what it will not solve.
- Manufacturing ROI calculatorAnswer a few questions about your shop floor, shifts and downtime to estimate your potential ROI with LeanSuite.

