An employee suggestion system is a defined process for collecting improvement ideas from the people who do the work, deciding on each idea within a set time, acting on the good ones, and answering the person who submitted it. This guide covers what a suggestion system is in manufacturing, where the idea came from, how it works, what research says, a worked example, common mistakes, and how to start and measure one.
What an Employee Suggestion System Is in Manufacturing
Definition and Purpose
In a plant, an employee suggestion system gives operators and other team members a route to propose improvements to their own work, with a named person who decides on each idea and a way to return the answer. Michael Ballé of the Lean Enterprise Institute begins with a question: what problem is the plant trying to solve? He contrasts a project that administers suggestions to pick and reward the best ones with a project that builds employee engagement and involvement.
The choice shapes every later design decision. Ballé favors engagement and writes that the issue is not the tool itself, but the kaizen intent behind the tool. Kaizen: A Complete Guide to Continuous Improvement in Manufacturing describes that intent in full.
Suggestion Box Versus Suggestion System
A suggestion box is only a place to leave ideas. A system adds the parts that keep people submitting: a time limit for a decision, a named decision maker, feedback to the submitter, and recognition. Ballé notes that Toyota did use suggestion boxes early on, and that the tool mattered less than the intent behind it. This split between box and system is a practical reading, not a source claim.
Turning Suggestion Boxes into Manufacturing Profit Generators takes the financial view of replacing a dead box, and 5 Strategies to Engage Factory Floor Teams Effectively covers engagement more broadly. Kaizen Teian: Individual Improvement Suggestions covers the individual proposal form.
Good to Know: Ballé and Steve Ansuini, who set up the suggestion system at Toyota's Georgetown plant, both describe Toyota practice. Neither gives outcome data for any plant, so the benefits described here are the purposes of the practices, not measured results.
Key Insight: An employee suggestion system is a process with a decision, an answer, and a purpose, not a box. Ballé places its value in the kaizen intent behind the tool.
Where the Employee Suggestion System Came From
Ford's Plan and Toyota's Copy
Mark Graban of Lean Blog recounts a 1997 talk by Masao Nemoto, a former Toyota executive, reproduced in The Birth of Lean. In that account Toyota copied its suggestion system directly from Ford, translated Ford's booklet into Japanese, and changed every mention of Ford to Toyota. Ford's plan gave the employee half of the financial benefit.
Ballé adds that Eiji Toyoda studied the Ford system and that it was geared toward profitability.
What Toyota Changed
In Nemoto's account, as Graban reports it, Ford's suggestions often concerned work outside the submitter's own workplace, while nearly all of Toyota's concerned the submitter's own workplace. Some Toyota employees even proposed ways to reduce staffing in their own areas, which Nemoto considered unthinkable in the United States. Graban links that willingness to job security.
Toyoda says Toyota did not go out of its way to promote team suggestions, and Graban reports that Toyota's suggestions became more team-based and more substantive over time.
Good to Know: Graban's view that the difference in results came from the surrounding management system is his interpretation, not a sourced finding. The article gives no counts of suggestions or adoption for either company.
Key Insight: Toyota took Ford's plan and aimed it at the submitter's own work, not at other departments. The account gives no results data, so the lesson concerns design, not numbers.
How an Employee Suggestion System Works
From Submission to Decision
Ballé describes a form that the team leader helps the operator write, including the before, the after, and the expected gain. The area supervisor owns a visual board that moves each idea through four stages: New, Accepted within the week, Requiring more than one week to be evaluated, and Realized. The plant manager checks the boards to confirm ideas are handled quickly.
At Toyota Georgetown, Ansuini writes, supervisors had five working days to approve or reject a suggestion, and ideas affecting other areas went out for review within 10 days. Supervisors could approve up to $200 in materials without manager approval. Idea Management: From Submission to Implementation follows an idea through these stages in detail.
Feedback and Recognition
Ansuini says an approved suggestion returned to the submitter as a signed copy, which he calls a legal contract, so members should keep a copy. Points were awarded per approved suggestion, from 10 to 10,000. Under 500 points earned a non-cash certificate, and 500 points or more earned cash, paid between pay weeks so it stood out from regular pay. Ansuini adds that awards from quality circles for improvement ideas also went through the suggestion system, so the plant did not run competing recognition programs.
Supervisors presented checks during shop-floor huddles without announcing amounts, and a quarterly advisory committee of mostly hourly workers gave feedback on preferred rewards. Employee Suggestion Systems: Best Practices for Manufacturing compares these options.
Key Insight: At Toyota Georgetown, supervisors decided within five working days and approved ideas came back as a signed copy. A fast, written answer is the core of the process.
What Research Says About Employee Suggestion Systems
The Leach, Stride and Wood Survey
Leach, Stride and Wood published a cross-sectional survey of 182 UK organizations, fielded in 2000 and 2001, in the International Journal of Innovation Management in 2006. One scheme manager answered for each organization, and 88 of them were members of ideasUK. By principal type the schemes were 98 centralized, 16 decentralized, 13 work-based, and 50 informal.
The paper does not report industries, so its results are not specific to manufacturing.
What Predicted Success
The authors call publicity and non-monetary rewards the most decisive features regardless of scheme type. Management support was the only feature uniquely tied to the implementation rate. Decentralized schemes had the highest suggestion rate, an estimated 0.81 per employee against 0.16 for centralized schemes with design features held constant, and work-based schemes had the highest perceived success.
Evidence for monetary rewards was weak. The mean suggestion rate was 1.27 per employee, but the median was 0.13, so a typical scheme sat far below the average.
Good to Know: The survey is cross-sectional, so it cannot show cause and effect. Data were missing for 25 percent of suggestion rates and 45 percent of implementation rates, one respondent spoke for each organization, and counts do not capture idea quality. The paper did not test evaluation methods or feedback speed.
Key Insight: In 182 UK organizations, publicity and non-monetary rewards were the most consistent predictors of success, and management support alone tracked implementation. The study cannot show cause and effect.
A Worked Example of an Employee Suggestion System
The Setup
An 80-operator plant with four supervisors borrows three Toyota Georgetown details from Ansuini: a five-working-day decision, supervisor approval of up to $200 in materials, and a $25 certificate for each implemented idea. Ballé's four-stage board tracks every idea. Supervisors take a 4-hour course at an assumed $45 an hour, which is $720, and each operator takes a 1-hour overview at an assumed $32, which is $2,560. The board costs $300, so setup totals $3,580.
The First Quarter
Operators submit 40 ideas, which is 0.5 per employee. Supervisors spend half an hour on each decision, or 20 hours, which is $900. They approve 30 ideas and the teams implement 24 in the quarter, a 60 percent share of those submitted. Materials average $50 an idea, or $1,200, and certificates cost $600, so the quarter's running cost is $2,700.
The Return
Each implemented idea saves an assumed $400 a year, so the 24 ideas return $9,600 over 12 months. Setup and the first quarter cost $6,280 in total, which leaves a net of $3,320 from that one quarter's ideas. The cost repays in about 34 weeks. Every figure is an illustration, and the sources reviewed give no suggestion-system return benchmarks.
Key Insight: In this example, a $6,280 start-up and first quarter produced 24 implemented ideas worth about $9,600 a year, which repays in about 34 weeks. Every figure is an illustration, not a benchmark.
Common Mistakes in Employee Suggestion Systems
Several recurring mistakes weaken a suggestion system in practice:
- Treating the system as a box, when Ballé says the issue is the kaizen intent behind the tool.
- Leaving ideas without a decision time, when Toyota Georgetown set five working days.
- Giving the submitter no answer, when Ansuini returns a signed copy of every approved idea.
- Skipping supervisor training, when Ballé says engagement depends on training frontline managers to support the process.
- Running competing recognition programs, when Ansuini routes quality circle awards through the suggestion system.
- Relying on cash alone, when Leach, Stride and Wood found weak evidence for monetary rewards.
- Keeping the system quiet, when publicity was among the strongest predictors in their survey.
- Rejecting small ideas, when Ansuini says any improvement, no matter how small, is beneficial.
- Judging by idea counts alone, which the survey notes do not capture quality.
Key Insight: Most failures come from slow decisions, silent answers, and untrained supervisors. A plant avoids them with a decision time, a written reply, trained supervisors, and visible recognition.
Starting and Measuring an Employee Suggestion System
Start With Purpose and Supervisors
Ballé says the management team should first discuss the purpose of the system, and that frontline managers must be trained to support it. At Georgetown, Ansuini describes four hours of supervisor training and a one-hour overview for team members. Supervisors did not submit ideas for their members and instead coached them by asking questions.
At launch the company president mailed a letter to every hourly employee's home so families could see the announcement, and the system at first valued quantity over quality. Employee Suggestion Systems: Best Practices for Manufacturing takes up publicity and rewards in more depth.
Measure the System
Ballé describes a plant in northern Spain where the plant manager tracked one number daily, the count of suggestions made the day before. A plant can add the participation rate, the share of ideas decided on time, and the share implemented. These additions are practical readings, not source claims.
A board that shows each idea's stage also shows which ideas have waited longest, which is the earliest sign of a slow decision. This is a practical reading, not a source claim. Counts miss quality, as Leach, Stride and Wood note among their limitations, so savings per idea belong beside the counts. Idea Management: From Submission to Implementation extends these measures along the workflow.
Key Insight: Start with a stated purpose and trained supervisors, then track the daily count and the share decided on time. Counts alone miss idea quality, so pair them with results.
Within the Lean System
Connection to Lean Principles
The Toyota Production System: A Complete Guide rests on continuous improvement and respect for people, and Ballé quotes Eiji Toyoda's vision to engage every mind, so a suggestion route turns that vision into a daily routine. Standard Work in Manufacturing: A Complete Guide gives accepted ideas a place to land, because an improvement that is not written into the standard is lost at the next shift change.
Connection to Lean Tools
Production Boards: Real-Time Team Communication on the Shop Floor can hold the four-stage idea board so the team sees the status of every suggestion. Tier Boards: Cascading Daily Management Explained can carry the counts of ideas decided and implemented up the meeting chain, which lets managers see where decisions are late.
Connection to Continuous Improvement
Kaizen: A Complete Guide to Continuous Improvement in Manufacturing supplies the problem-solving intent behind every suggestion. Kaizen Teian: Individual Improvement Suggestions covers the individual proposal, since small ideas from operators are the daily form of kaizen and need a route that reaches a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an employee suggestion system in manufacturing?
It is a defined process for collecting improvement ideas from the people who do the work, deciding on each within a set time, acting on good ideas, and answering the submitter. Ballé says purpose matters most: administering ideas to reward the best, or building employee involvement.
Where did the employee suggestion system come from?
In Nemoto's account, reported by Graban, Toyota copied Ford's system, translating its booklet and replacing Ford with Toyota. Ford paid the employee half of the financial benefit and took ideas about other areas, while nearly all of Toyota's ideas concerned the submitter's own workplace, per that account.
How fast should a suggestion be decided?
Toyota Georgetown gave supervisors five working days to approve or reject, with ideas affecting other areas reviewed within 10 days, according to Ansuini. Ballé describes a one-week threshold on a visual board. Neither reports results, so a plant sets its own limit and tracks it.
Do cash rewards make a suggestion system work?
The evidence is weak. Leach, Stride and Wood found publicity and non-monetary rewards the most consistent predictors of success, with weak evidence for monetary rewards, in a UK survey that cannot show cause. Toyota Georgetown used certificates below 500 points and cash at 500 or more.
What should a plant measure?
Ballé's plant manager tracked the number of suggestions made the day before at a plant in northern Spain. A plant can add the participation rate, the share decided on time, and the share implemented, though counts miss idea quality. These additions are practical readings, not source claims.
Want our lean manufacturing guides first in Google? Add us as a preferred source.
Add LeanSuite as a preferred source on Google (opens in a new tab)







