Skip to content
LeanSuite
Lean Manufacturing Education

Kanban Card Types: Production, Withdrawal, Signal, Two-Bin and Electronic

Production, withdrawal, signal, two-bin and electronic kanban: what each does, how the loop works, and how to work out how many cards you need, with worked examples.

Author
Content Architect ·
Published
Updated
Reading time
19 min
Flat illustration of a fan of kanban cards, a pair of bins with a card between them and an operator with a tablet signalling a refill

There are three kinds of kanban in the Toyota Production System: production, withdrawal and signal. Withdrawal kanban has an internal form (between processes) and an external one (supplier kanban). Two-bin and electronic kanban are not extra kinds. They are ways of carrying the signal: an empty bin instead of a card, or a scan instead of paper. The Lean Enterprise Institute lexicon uses the same split.

Choose by the job. A production kanban tells a process what to make. A withdrawal kanban tells a handler what to move. A signal kanban tells a batch process that stock has fallen to the point where it must start. A two-bin loop does the work with two containers and no card. Whichever you choose, the number of cards or bins comes from one formula, worked below with arithmetic you can check. For how kanban supports visual scheduling across a plant, see kanban pull systems and visual scheduling, which this post extends.

The kinds of kanban at a glance

  • Production kanban. What it authorizes: Make one container of a part. Use it when: A process feeds a store and can make small, frequent batches.
  • Withdrawal kanban (interprocess). What it authorizes: Move one container from a store to the using process. Use it when: Parts travel between processes inside the plant.
  • Supplier kanban. What it authorizes: Deliver one container from an outside supplier. Use it when: Parts are bought and the supplier delivers on a fixed rhythm.
  • Signal kanban (triangle). What it authorizes: Start a batch when stock falls to a set level. Use it when: Changeovers are long, so one container at a time is not possible.
  • Two-bin. What it authorizes: Refill the empty bin. Use it when: Cheap, steady, small parts such as fasteners.
  • Electronic. What it authorizes: Any of the above, carried by a scan or system entry. Use it when: Cards would travel too far or too slowly.

How the loop physically works

The standard two-card loop, as described by Cambridge's Institute for Manufacturing: a worker at the using process collects withdrawal kanban and the empty containers they belong to, and walks to the store of the process upstream. They take full containers and remove the production kanban riding on each. That production kanban goes into a post box at the supplying process. The withdrawal kanban goes onto the full container, which returns to the using process.

At the supplying process, production kanban come out of the post box in the order they arrived. Each is an instruction to make one container of that part. When it is done, the card rides on the container into the store. Consumption downstream is the only thing that creates work upstream. That is the pull.

The two-card loop between a using process and its supplier
  1. 1

    Collect withdrawal kanban and empties

    At the using process
  2. 2

    Walk to the upstream store

    Take full containers; remove the production kanban riding on each
  3. 3

    Production kanban into the post box

    At the supplying process, worked in order of arrival
  4. 4

    Withdrawal kanban onto the container

    The full container returns to the using process
  5. 5

    Make one container per card

    The card rides the finished container into the store

Consumption downstream is the only thing that creates work upstream

Production, withdrawal and supplier kanban

Production kanban is the instruction card for the supplying process: which part, and the quantity of one container. It sits on a full container in the store, drops into the post box when the container is taken, and returns on the container once it is made. Per the LEI lexicon, typical fields are part name and number, supplier information, quantity and storage location. Our kanban card template adds the producing process, container type and a card number such as 3 of 5, so anyone can see how many cards the loop should hold. Use it when the process can make one container at a time, or close to it. It fails when cards pile up unactioned in the post box, when containers are made without a card, or when lost cards quietly shrink the loop.

Withdrawal kanban (interprocess) authorizes moving one container from the store to the process that uses it. It travels with the handler on a fixed route, swaps places with the production kanban at the store, and rides back on the full container. Fields: part, quantity per container, the location it comes from and goes to, container type, card number. Use it when material moves between a supermarket and the line, or between two cells, ideally on a timed route such as a water spider runs. It fails when handlers move containers without swapping cards, so stock exists that no card accounts for, or when the route runs late and cards wait at the point of use.

Supplier kanban is the withdrawal kanban for an outside supplier. The LEI lexicon names it as the external form and notes that, over long distances, it typically takes an electronic form. The card goes to the supplier when a container is consumed, the supplier ships the same container quantity on an agreed rhythm, and the empty container comes back. Add supplier name, delivery point and delivery times to the card. Use it for bought parts with steady demand. It fails when cards are returned in batches (the supplier sees demand in lumps), when transit is longer than the loop was sized for, or when the pack on the card no longer matches the pack shipped.

Signal kanban

A signal kanban triggers production of a batch when stock reaches a minimum. The LEI lexicon gives the case: a stamping press with short cycle times and long changeovers, where making one container at a time would waste the press. The triangle card is the usual form, though only one type of signal. IFM describes the card as inserted near the bottom of a stack so that production starts when stock reaches a preset reorder level.

The card sits inside the stack of containers at a marked position. Containers are drawn from the top. When the draw-down reaches the card, whoever takes that container removes it and sends it to the scheduler of the batch process. The press makes a batch and the stack is refilled. On the card: part, batch size, container quantity, making process and trigger position. Use it when changeovers are long enough that the process must run batches. It fails when the trigger position is guessed. Too high and you carry stock the batch did not need. Too low and the line runs dry while the press is still changing over. A worked trigger is below.

Two-bin kanban

Two identical containers of a part. The part is used from bin one. When bin one is empty it becomes the signal, and bin two supplies the line while bin one is refilled. The empty bin goes to the refill point or is picked up on a route, and the refilled bin goes back behind the one in use. There is usually no card, only a shelf label with part number, bin size and reorder rule.

How a two-bin loop runs
  1. 1

    Use the part from bin one

    Two identical containers of the part
  2. 2

    Bin one empties: it is the signal

    Usually no card, only a shelf label with part number, bin size and reorder rule
  3. 3

    Bin two supplies the line

    While bin one is refilled
  4. 4

    Refill the empty bin

    It goes to the refill point or is picked up on a route
  5. 5

    Refilled bin goes behind

    Behind the one in use

The refilled bin goes back behind the one in use, and the loop repeats

Use it when the part is cheap, used steadily and not worth a card or a scan, such as fasteners and small hardware. It fails when bin two is sized for a typical day instead of the whole replenishment lead time, when empty bins sit unnoticed, or when people open bin two before bin one is empty. It also leaves no consumption record.

Electronic kanban

The signal is carried by a barcode scan or a system entry instead of a physical card. The container still moves physically, only the card became data. Each request carries a timestamp, which is the real advantage: you can compare actual replenishment time with the lead time you assumed when sizing. It earns its cost for distant suppliers and where cards get lost.

It fails when scans are skipped, when the system balance drifts from what is on the shelf, or when a signal exists in the system that nobody on the floor can see. Electronic kanban does not change the arithmetic. Fixing a bad loop size with software only makes the wrong number arrive faster.

How many kanban you need

Number of kanban = (demand during the replenishment lead time + safety stock) / container quantity, rounded up.

Sizing the loop, with the post's assumed figuresIllustrative example

Number of kanban = (demand during replenishment lead time + safety stock) / container quantity, rounded up

Demand during lead time
Daily demand x lead time in days; lead time is the card's full trip around the loop, not run time alone
Safety stock
A safety factor management chooses; no measurement gives it
Container quantity
Pieces per container, no more than about a tenth of daily demand

Worked example

Demand during lead time
600 x 0.5 day = 300 pieces
With 20% safety
300 x 1.2 = 360 pieces
Divided by the container
360 / 50 = 7.2
Kanban
8 cards, rounded up

The post's assumed figures: 600 pieces a day, a 4-hour (0.5 day) lead time, containers of 50, 20% safety. Seven cards would cover 350 pieces, 10 short of 360, so the eighth is taken.

The Toyota form, which Kundu, Rossini and Portioli-Staudacher cite in their 2019 paper as the "Toyota formula" after Sugimori and colleagues (1977), is y = D (Tw + Tp) (1 + α) / a, where y is the number of kanban, D is demand per unit of time, Tw and Tp are the waiting and processing time of one kanban, a is container capacity (the paper puts it at no more than 10% of daily demand) and α is the safety factor, which the paper calls a policy variable and notes is below 10%. No measurement gives you α. Management chooses it: it is the cushion you are willing to pay for. Co and Sharafali study the same idea in IIE Transactions, Toyota's use of a constant overplanning factor on average demand during the replenishment cycle.

Worked example (assumed figures). Daily demand 600 pieces on an 8-hour day. Replenishment lead time, from card detached to full container back in the store: 4 hours, which is 0.5 day. In this example, the container holds 50 pieces (8.3% of daily demand). Safety factor assumed at 20%, deliberately generous so the effect of rounding is easy to see.

  • Demand during lead time: 600 x 0.5 = 300 pieces.
  • With safety: 300 x 1.2 = 360 pieces.
  • Kanban: 360 / 50 = 7.2, rounded up to 8.

Rounding is not neutral. Seven cards cover 350 pieces, 10 short of 360, so you take the eighth. The loop then holds up to 8 x 50 = 400 pieces, about two thirds of a day of demand.

Now move the policy variable. At α = 10%: 300 x 1.1 = 330, and 330 / 50 = 6.6, so 7 cards. At α = 0: 300 / 50 = 6 cards. Same part, same demand, same lead time: six, seven or eight cards depending on the cushion you decide to carry. The 10% and 25% factors in the next two examples are assumed values as well. Write the α you used in the card register beside the count so the next person can challenge it.

Lead time is the full trip of a card around the loop (post box wait, making, moving, store wait), not only run time. Our kanban sizing calculator uses the same form (daily demand x lead time in days x (1 + safety factor) / quantity per container, rounded up).

Same part, same lead time: the safety factor decides six, seven or eight cardsIllustrative example
  • Safety factor 0: 300 / 50 = 66 kanban cards for the same part
  • Safety factor 10%: 330 / 50 = 6.6, so 77 kanban cards for the same part
  • Safety factor 20%: 360 / 50 = 7.2, so 88 kanban cards for the same part

Same part, demand and lead time as the worked example; only the cushion changes. Write the factor you used in the card register so the next person can challenge it.

A signal kanban with the trigger worked out

A stamping press makes a bracket. Assumptions: downstream use 600 a day; containers of 50; batch size set by the changeover at 1,800 pieces (36 containers, three days of demand); lead time from trigger to full batch in the store of 2 working days, covering the wait for the press, a 45-minute changeover, a 6-hour run at an assumed 300 pieces an hour, and transport; safety factor 10%.

  • Demand during lead time: 600 x 2 = 1,200 pieces.
  • With safety: 1,200 x 1.1 = 1,320 pieces.
  • Trigger: 1,320 / 50 = 26.4, rounded up to 27 containers.

Insert the signal card so 27 containers lie below it. If the batch arrives together at the end of the two days, stock just before arrival is 27 x 50 minus 1,200 = 150 pieces (3 containers), the cushion. Right after arrival it peaks at 150 + 1,800 = 1,950 pieces, 39 containers. The 2-day lead time is shorter than the 3-day batch cycle, so the press is not behind its own demand. The trigger sizes the safety, the batch size sizes the peak, and a longer changeover pushes up the batch size, not the trigger.

Where the signal card sits in the stackIllustrative example
Containers drawn from the topJust before the batch arrives about 3 containers (150 pieces) remain: the cushion
  1. Stock above the card

    Up to 39 containers right after a batch arrives: the 150 pieces left plus the 1,800-piece batch

  2. Signal card

    Whoever takes this container sends the card to the scheduler of the press

  3. 27 containers below the card

    1,320 pieces: two days of demand (1,200) plus 10% safety, divided by 50 and rounded up from 26.4

The post's assumptions: 600 a day, containers of 50, a batch of 1,800 (36 containers), 2 working days from trigger to full batch, 10% safety.

A two-bin loop with the bin sized

A purchased M8 bolt. Assumptions: usage 380 a day; replenishment lead time 3 working days; safety factor 25%; pack size 250.

Each bin must cover the whole lead time, because bin one is empty when the clock starts and bin two is all you have.

  • Demand during lead time: 380 x 3 = 1,140.
  • With safety: 1,140 x 1.25 = 1,425.
  • Bin size: 1,425 / 250 = 5.7, rounded up to 6 packs, 1,500 pieces per bin.

Under these assumptions stock peaks near 1,860 pieces: when the refilled bin returns, bin two still holds 1,500 minus 1,140 = 360. That is about 4.9 days of demand, and the shelf needs two bin positions. MetricGate's two-bin policy page states the same rule: bin size is mean demand over lead time plus safety, rounded up to the container multiple, with total stock up to twice the bin size.

Choosing the type for each part

The part decides the type, not a plant standard, so one plant runs several at once (the table above is the short version). Design the signal together with the supermarket or point of use it fills: the refill quantity of one layer is the consumption signal of the next, as the point-of-use storage post explains.

Choosing the kanban type for one part
  1. 1Decision

    Cheap, steady, small part?

    Yes:
    Yes: two-bin loop; the empty bin is the signal, a shelf label and no card
    No:
    No: next question
  2. 2Decision

    Bought from an outside supplier?

    Yes:
    Yes: supplier kanban, electronic over long distances
    No:
    No: next question
  3. 3Decision

    Can it make one container at a time?

    Yes:
    Yes: production kanban, with withdrawal kanban to move it
    No:
    No: signal kanban; a batch starts when stock falls to the trigger
  4. 4Decision

    Cards too far or too slow to travel?

    Yes:
    Yes: carry the signal electronically; the arithmetic does not change
    No:
    No: paper cards
  5. 5

    Write it into standard work

    Signal type and card count. To switch types, run both for one replenishment cycle, confirm the new trigger, retire the old one on a named date

The part decides the type, not a plant standard, so one plant runs several at once.

Write the chosen signal and the card count into the part's standard work so every shift runs it the same way. If you switch a part to another signal, run both for one fixed period, for example one replenishment cycle. Confirm the new one triggers at the right quantity, then retire the old one on a named date and take the old cards away. An open-ended overlap is where stockouts and confusion happen.

The rules of kanban

Wikipedia lists Toyota's six rules for applying kanban:

  1. Each process asks its supplier for more by sending a kanban when it uses its parts.
  2. Each process makes parts in the quantity and sequence of the kanban it receives.
  3. Nothing is made or moved without a kanban.
  4. The kanban stays attached to the goods.
  5. Defective items are never passed on.
  6. Limiting the number of kanban makes the process more sensitive and reveals inefficiencies.

AllAboutLean reports a differently worded six from Toyota's 1973 Production System Handbook, including that kanban is a means of fine tuning. Both lists agree on what matters: pull, no card no work, quality at source, and a card count you work to reduce.

On the last rule, Lean Enterprise Institute writers describe taking cards out of circulation as the way to surface problems, because fewer cards leave less time to react. Change the count at a scheduled review, not by adding cards whenever the line runs short. A shortage is a signal to examine the loop, not to enlarge it. IFM puts the working range plainly: kanban helps fine tune production to demand changes of up to plus or minus 10%. Beyond that, resize the loop.

When not to use kanban

  • Demand is rare or lumpy. A part used a few times a year would carry a card and a container all year. Make it to order.
  • The schedule is not levelled. Kanban absorbs modest swings, within the plus or minus 10% range the Institute for Manufacturing gives above. If the schedule jumps by half from week to week, level it first with production leveling, then size the loops.
  • The process is unstable. Adding cards to protect the line from breakdowns and defects hides the problems the cards should expose.
  • The lead time is very long. If a supplier needs months, the loop would hold months of stock. Plan those parts against a forecast and review often.
  • A buffer is not needed. Where two processes can sit side by side, a FIFO lane caps the queue without cards, and one-piece flow removes the store.

The Kanban method used in software and knowledge work, with columns and work in progress limits, is a different tool, covered in the four core principles of Kanban. The cards here are the factory loop, where the card count is the work in progress limit.

Tools, takt and leveling

Demand in the formula should come from the customer rate, which takt time is built from. Levelled demand keeps the card count stable, and our heijunka box planner spreads kanban across the day. The kanban card template has six production and six withdrawal cards plus a card register. The kanban sizing calculator works out the count for each part. The kanban rules poster is for the wall at the store. If you want the loop register and the monthly count review on a shared board, Lean Studio can hold them, but LeanSuite does not generate kanban signals from machines or sensors.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main types of kanban? Production kanban, withdrawal kanban and signal kanban. Withdrawal kanban splits into interprocess kanban inside the plant and supplier kanban for outside suppliers. Two-bin and electronic kanban describe how the signal is carried, not a separate kind of authorization.

What is the difference between a production kanban and a withdrawal kanban? A production kanban tells a process what and how much to make. A withdrawal kanban tells a handler what to move from a store to the using process. In a two-card loop the two swap places at the store, which links making and moving.

How do I calculate how many kanban cards I need? Divide demand during the replenishment lead time plus safety stock by the container quantity, and round up. For 600 pieces a day, a half-day lead time, 20% safety and containers of 50, that is 600 x 0.5 x 1.2 / 50 = 7.2, so 8 cards. The safety factor is a management choice, so record the one you used.

When should I use a signal kanban instead of a production kanban? Use a signal kanban when changeovers are long enough that the process has to run batches, such as a stamping press. Set the trigger at demand during the batch lead time plus safety. Use a production kanban when the process can make one container at a time.

Is electronic kanban better than cards? No. It suits distant suppliers and loops where cards get lost, and it timestamps every signal. It does not change the sizing formula, and a badly sized loop is still badly sized when it is electronic.

Sources

Free for this topic: Standard work sheet template, SMED changeover worksheet, Takt time calculator

Want our lean manufacturing guides first in Google? Add us as a preferred source.

Add LeanSuite as a preferred source on Google (opens in a new tab)